This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.
Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping Free Domestic Shipping & Returns

Curated Mystery Box

Ring Size5
Necklace Length16 inch
Bracelet Length6.5 inch

Discover the excitement of our Mystery Box – reminiscent of the childhood excitement but curated for the grown-up you! Unbox 3-4 carefully selected pieces tailored uniquely for you, featuring a mix of necklaces, rings, earrings, bracelets, or pendants with a combined value of at least $145 or more. 

How do I order? 

Simply pick your preferred sizes when placing your order.

What will be in my box?

The element of surprise is central to the experience, and we can't reveal the exact contents of each box – it's all part of the excitement! While we can't give away the surprise element, we can assess your past purchases in the system to ensure we do not send you a repeated style that you already own.

What if I have a metal preference? 

Add a note at checkout if you have a metal preference: 14k gold fill or sterling silver. If we do not hear from you we will default to gold fill, silver or a mix! 

Important Info

While we're curating your preferences, please note that all mystery boxes are final sale and may be shipped separately from other items in your order. Immerse yourself in the joy of these hand-picked pieces and let the magic unfold.

Metals We Use

We exclusively use solid gold, gold fill, and sterling silver materials in making each of our designs.

We sustainably source + use recycled materials to create each piece.

Return Policy

We provide a 90-day warranty and a 7-day return policy. Terms and conditions apply. Learn more here.

Tag Your SMJ + Review

We have a growing community on Instagram! Follow us at @sheenamarshalljewelry and tag us. We love to see our creations in real life. While you're at it, leave us a glowing review to help others just like you discover us.

Free shipping on orders over $75

Handmade for you in Denver, CO

Made from recycled gold and silver

Raw materials 100% USA sourced

Curated Mystery Box



Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $75 away from free shipping.
No more products available for purchase

Your Cart is Empty